Showing posts with label no bake cookies didn't set. Show all posts
Showing posts with label no bake cookies didn't set. Show all posts

Wednesday, October 23, 2013

Change of Pace

Stepping away from my creative crafty side, I want to talk about other things.  Too much has been whirling in my mind and I need to purge.

Baking has been my oldest hobby.  It certainly became my therapy in recent years.  Although lately, since being diagnosed as a diabetic, I don't eat any of my baking.  Thankfully, with my husband's job, I have hundreds of greedy mouths to pawn off all my creations.  I mainly stick to cookies, but I'll do brownies or muffins and such for a change. 
In my eagerness to try something new, I decided to make some no-bake cookies.  I remember making some as a teen over at a friend's house.  I remember pretzels (or chow mein noodles -- something crunchy like that), peanuts and melted chocolate and butterscotch.  I remember there was no oven.  And I certainly don't remember a stove.  I remember melting the chocolate in the microwave.

However, when I went searching online for some no-bake cookie recipes, every last one of them involved boiling a sugar mixture on the stovetop. 

I have several issues with this:

1.  While technically this is a no-bake recipe, it still involves cooking.  I thought the idea was to not heat up the house while making these????  {for the record, I call these recipes 'cooked cookies'}
2.  Cooking sugar to the soft-ball stage is tricky, and certainly not for the beginner candy-maker.
3.  All the sites bragged about this being a kid-friendly cookie recipe.  I wouldn't let kids near a stove with boiling sugar.  This mixture can cause some serious burns.

Anyway, I selected a recipe and proceeded to combine the ingredients for the boil.  The recipe said to combine it all in a small saucepan.  Without thinking, I immediately pulled out my 1 quart saucepan.  I got the thing going and as soon as I got the little bubbles starting to form on my sugar mixture, I realized my mistake.  This pot was going to boil over.  This type of candy boils up big.  I remember from my lollipop making days that sugar forms lots of foamy big bubbles.  If I was to do this again, I wouldn't use a 2 quart pot either; I'd go big...like 3-4 quart, which I consider to be a LARGE saucepan.  Small saucepan...who wrote this recipe?

After dealing with the boilover and trying to recover as much as I could, I was finally at the 'mix all the ingredients together' stage.  It was hard to stir.  Very hard.  When I got it completely coated, I dumped it all in a lined cake pan.  I wanted to cut this into bars.  So I spread it out and left it alone to set for the recommended 30 minutes.  Two hours later (because I get distracted easily), I went to de-pan my cookies and cut them into squares.  However, my cookies weren't set.  They were still the ooey-gooey mess they were when I dumped them in the pan.  I tried chilling the pan; no good.  I went back to the web and searched for a way to save my cookies.  Nada.   Most sites let on that all you could do was dump the goop in the trash.  Not this chick.  There's a lot of chocolate, oats, sugar, peanut butter, etc. in this mix.  I don't habitually throw money in the trash.  Being at a loss, I packed the mixture in an airtight container and stuck it in the fridge until I could figure out what to do with it.

Fast forward one week.  I'd been thinking about it all week and finally decided that since all the ingredients in this no-bake cookie recipe were basically the same as a regular cookie recipe minus a few, I could add the missing few and just make a regular baked cookie.  I pulled the container of goop out of the fridge and it was still as gooey as it was when I put it in.  I mixed it all with another stick of softened butter.  Added two beaten eggs.  Then I added 2-1/2 cups of flour with some salt & baking soda.  Mix till blended and I scooped and baked for 10 minutes.  They came out delicious.  I had saved my disastrous no-bake cookies.  I will feed them to my cadets tonight and I'm sure they will enjoy the chocolaty, oaty, peanut buttery cookies.

I doubt that I will attempt that no-bake cookie recipe again, but I know that if I did and failed again, I know how to save it.  Too bad I can't contact others who have had unlucky no-bake cookie flops before they chuck it in the trash, but perhaps somebody will find my blog and be rescued.